Choose a Stone

All of the stones in this collection are compatible with your selected setting. We will adjust the fit as needed.

Stones that Fit Rectangular Settings

Filter Right
177 products
Most relevantBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED E VS1 RADIANT CUT LOOSE COLORLESS 2ct
$4,043.00
Sold out
0.33ct N VS1 ASSCHER CUT DIAMOND NATURAL SQUARE SHAPE STEP LOOSE 1/3 CARAT
$433.00
Sold out
VINTAGE 1.5ct J VVS2 GIA CERTIFIED CARRE FRENCH CUT DIAMOND LOOSE SQUARE NATURAL
$7,515.00
Sold out
3.05ct EMERALD CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED W-X VS2 CHAMPAGNE LOOSE NATURAL 3 CARAT
$16,772.00
Sold out
1.5ct GIA CERTIFIED J VS1 PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND LOOSE NATURAL ENGAGEMENT RADIANT
$5,201.00
Sold out
3.39ct GIA CERTIFIED SAPPHIRE EMERALD CUT LOOSE NATURAL GEMSTONE 3.5 CARAT
$5,779.00
Sold out
0.58ct EMERALD CUT DIAMOND H-I VS2 5.9mm LONG RATIO NATURAL STEP CUT EARTH MINED
$861.00
Sold out
0.97ct GIA CERTIFIED D VS1 DIAMOND EMERALD CUT LOOSE NATURAL COLORLESS 1 CARAT
$3,832.00
Sold out
2.22ct EMERALD LOOSE STONE LONG EMERALD CUT NATURAL LOOSE GEMSTONE PASTEL GREEN
$717.00
Sold out
1.21ct E-F VS ASSCHER CUT DIAMOND 5 STONE LAYOUT VINTAGE PARCEL LOOSE NATURAL
$1,952.00
Sold out
2.29ct COLOMBIAN EMERALD MINOR OIL LOOSE MINT GREEN GEMSTONE NATURAL EMERALD CUT
$1,122.00
Sold out
1.57ct RICH GREEN EMERALD LOOSE NATURAL GEMSTONE EMERALD SHAPE CUT 1.5 CARAT
$1,584.00
Sold out
3.20ct COLOMBIAN EMERALD LOOSE GEMSTONE MINT GREEN EMERALD SHAPE CUT NATURAL
$572.00
Sold out
1/2 CARAT I SI1-SI2 PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND LOOSE NATURAL ENGAGEMENT SQUARE 0.5ct
$688.00
Sold out
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND F VS2 IGI CERTIFIED PRINCESS CUT SQUARE SHAPE LOOSE
$1,874.00 VIP discount available
1 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND CERTIFIED E VVS2 EMERALD SHAPE CUT LOOSE COLORLESS
$1,295.00
Sold out
LAB CREATED 2.06ct D VS1 ANTIQUE EMERALD CUT DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED ENGAGEMENT
$2,096.00
Sold out
LAB CREATED 2.04ct E VVS2 ANTIQUE EMERALD CUT DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED ENGAGEMENT
$2,053.00
LAB CREATED 2.09ct E VS1 BRILLIANT EMERALD CUT DIAMOND OCTAGONAL IGI CERTIFIED
$2,018.00
LAB CREATED 2.05ct E VS1 BRILLIANT EMERALD CUT DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED OCTAGONAL
$1,981.00
1.51ct H SI1 EMERALD CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED ENGAGEMENT 1.5 CARAT LOOSE LONG
$7,370.00
0.45ct D-E SI2 ELONGATED RADIANT CUT DIAMOND LOOSE RECTANGLE SHAPE NATURAL STONE
$795.00
0.99ct I I1 PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED LOOSE ENGAGEMENT NATURAL 1 CARAT
$1,440.00
2.5 CARAT GIA CERTIFIED L VS2 EMERALD CUT DIAMOND NATURAL ENGAGEMENT LOOSE
$11,565.00
2 CARAT GIA CERTIFIED L VS1 EMERALD CUT DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT NATURAL LOOSE 2ct
$7,804.00
2 CARAT GIA CERTIFIED PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND K SI1 LOOSE NATURAL SQUARE ENGAGEMENT
$7,226.00
0.68c GIA CERTIFIED E VVS2 EMERALD CUT DIAMOND LONG BAGUETTE SHAPE NATURAL 7.5mm
$2,308.00
GIA CERTIFIED 0.58ct FANCY PINK BROWN EMERALD CUT DIAMOND SI1 NATURAL LOOSE
$3,609.00
3.87ct ASSCHER CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED K VVS2 LOOSE NATURAL SQUARE 4 CARAT 4ct
$39,048.00 VIP discount available
4.17ct ASSCHER CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED L VS2 LOOSE NATURAL SQUARE STEP CUT
$42,672.00
Sold out
1 CARAT GIA CERTIFIED FANCY YELLOW SI2 DIAMOND RADIANT CUT LOOSE NATURAL STONE
$3,609.00
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED E VS1 ANTIQUE STYLE EMERALD CUT LOOSE
$1,807.00
Sold out
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED E VS1 DEEP CORNER EMERALD CUT LOOSE
$1,807.00
Sold out
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED E VVS2 LOOSE DEEP CORNER EMERALD CUT
$1,952.00
2 CARAT LAB CREATED DIAMOND IGI CERTIFIED E VVS2 DEEP CORNER EMERALD CUT LOOSE
$2,018.00
Sold out
1.5ct PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND GIA CERTIFIED F SI2 LOOSE NATURAL SQUARE ENGAGEMENT
$6,647.00